Lost Pizza
Lost Pizza
Lost Pizza

Lost Pizza

Family Pizza restaurant in Benton, Arkansas

★ 4.2 77 reviews Pizza ✨ Casual dinner with family or friends

"Lost Pizza has become our family's favorite Pizza spot in Benton.

About Lost Pizza

Lost Pizza has carved out a distinctive niche in Little Rock’s dining scene, offering artisanal pizzas that blend creative toppings with traditional techniques. This locally-owned establishment provides a laid-back dining experience that appeals to both pizza purists and adventurous eaters looking for something beyond the ordinary chain offerings.

The menu showcases hand-tossed pizzas with house-made dough and locally-sourced ingredients when possible. Signature offerings include unique combinations like barbecue pulled pork with caramelized onions, gourmet white sauce pizzas topped with fresh herbs, and classic margherita preparations that highlight the quality of their San Marzano tomatoes. Beyond pizza, the kitchen serves fresh salads, appetizers, and a selection of craft beers that pair perfectly with their wood-fired creations.

The interior strikes a balance between rustic charm and modern comfort, featuring exposed brick walls, warm lighting, and communal-style seating that encourages conversation. Large windows flood the space with natural light during daytime visits, while the evening atmosphere becomes more intimate with dimmed lighting and the gentle sounds of the open kitchen preparing fresh orders.

Lost Pizza serves as an ideal destination for casual family dinners, date nights, or gatherings with friends who appreciate quality ingredients and creative culinary approaches. The restaurant’s commitment to fresh preparation means orders take a bit longer than fast-casual alternatives, but diners consistently find the wait worthwhile for the superior flavor and texture that comes from made-to-order preparation.

Must-Try Dishes

Recommended by locals and visitors

🍴 BBQ Pulled Pork Pizza
🍴 Margherita with Fresh Basil
🍴 White Sauce Pizza with Spinach and Ricotta

Recent Reviews

John M. ★★★★★

Stopped by again as I was traveling through Still great Really good thin crust Can't go wrong with the Otis House salad is a really nice addition Great...

2 months ago

Cassandra B. ★★

The pizza was a 4, but horrible service. No one welcomed or said anything as we left. No one smiled. No one came to check on us or make sure anything was...

Oct 31, 2025

Tonya M. ★★★★★

Wonderful very flavorful pizza. Great Service! I now been there twice and ordered takeout a couple of times. Same great experience every time. Highly recommend!

Jul 24, 2025

77 reviews via

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Lost Pizza located? +
Lost Pizza is located at 510 Hwy 5 N in Benton. The restaurant offers convenient parking nearby and is easily accessible from major roads in the Benton area.
What is the phone number for Lost Pizza? +
You can reach Lost Pizza by phone at (501) 794-6441. Calling ahead is recommended for reservations, takeout orders, or to confirm current hours and daily specials.
Do you have any insider tips for visiting Lost Pizza? +
Visit during weekday lunch hours to avoid the dinner rush and enjoy the same great pizzas with shorter wait times.

Contact & Reserve

Call Now

Hours

Loading...
Mon - Sun11:00 AM - 9:00 PM

Location

City: Benton

Phone: (501) 794-6441

Address: 510 Hwy 5 N

Why Choose This Place

  • Highly rated 4.2/5
  • 👥 Popular choice 77 reviews

Great For

Casual dinner with family or friends

Insider Tip

Visit during weekday lunch hours to avoid the dinner rush and enjoy the same great pizzas with shorter wait times.

Restaurant Vibes

👨‍👩‍👧 Family Friendly 😊 Casual Vibes ❤️ Local Favorite

Guest Satisfaction

84%

Own this business?

Claim your free listing to update your info and get the verified business badge.

Own this business?
Photo